KIRKUS
01 September 1995
MAKING MUSIC OUT OF MISERY
by Thomas DePietro
We are pleased to continue our series of commentaries on undeservedly
neglected books. Thomas DePietro, an advisory editor to the
cultural journal Italian-Americana, marks his tenth anniversary
this month as a reviewer for Kirkus. --Anne Larsen
If truth be told, ethnic novels resurrected in the spirit
of multicultural rediscovery seldom transcend their value as
sociology or group uplift. One exception is the work of Raymond
DeCapite, whose name keeps popping up on bibliographies of
forgotten Italian-American fiction. After publishing two novels
in the early '60s, DeCapite more or less disappeared from the
literary landscape (though he still lives and writes in his
native Cleveland).
His first novel, The Coming of Fabrizze (1960), is a celebration
of small working-class community in Cleveland during the '20s.
What distinguishes this almost mythic tale of an immigrant-who
succeeds by virtue of hard work and honesty-from other diaspora
narratives is not only its good-natured tone, but its poetic
language. With an amazing ear for the lyrical patterns of everyday
speech, DeCapite chronicles Fabrizze's eventual failure. But
it's not a down-and-out denouement: His neighbors still love
the man who brought them hope and joy and music.
A Lost King (1961), DeCapite's second published novel, is
a small masterpiece, so unique (and quiet) in spirit and style
that it's easy to see how it was lost in the literary maelstrom
of the time. For one thing, this elegant little novel beautifully
captures the double consciousness of American ethnicity in
its tale of emotional struggle between a son and his father.
The weary Old World realist, a worker retired from a Cleveland
factory, cannot fathom his carefree boy. A New World dreamer,
young Paul lost two thousand years of world history (as he
puts it) while mooning over robust Peggy Haley in class. But
he doesn't get the girl. Like everyone else in the neighborhood,
she can't figure out this almost moronically happy slacker.
Paul fails miserably at all the success-track jobs he pursues,
while he finds total contentment playing his harmonica ("making
music out of misery") and selling watermelons from a truck.
As the fires from the steel mill light the skies, Paul trades
barbs with his grumpy, nihilistic father. The writing is expert;
it's hard to think of any other novel that describes butchering
meat as a poetic dance. But such are the unexpected-and remarkable-pleasures
to be found in the long-out-of-print work of Raymond DeCapite.
< Back to reviews